| Brewery | Beer | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Bandwagon Brewery | Peanut Butter Chocolate Stout | Nice Roasty stout with a faint peanutty aftertaste. Really good! |
| Barrier Brewing | Ruthless IPA | A Rye IPA that's hoppy even to a hop lover. |
| Barrier Brewing | Rembrandt Porter | Fine, but hard to believe these guys won the F.X. Matt's trophy for best brewer in New York State... |
| Brewery Ommegang | Ommegang Adoration | God and yeasty, but a bit sour. |
| Captain Lawrence Brewing | Captain's Reserve Imperial IPA | ehh... |
| Chatham Brewing | Scotch Ale | Smoky Malted niceness. |
| Cortland Brewing | Heifer-Weisse (2nd tasting) | Still good! No spices, just Begian Yeast |
| Crossroads Brewing | Outrage IPA | It's okay. Won the Calen Prize. |
| Empire Brewing | Cream Ale | Cloudy at first, then clearing. Something off here |
| Empire Brewing | White Aphro (2nd tasting) | Still Awesome! What a great beer to finish TAP-NY with! |
| CH Evans Brewing | Kick Ass Brown | okay. Light on the mouthfeel. |
| Gilded Otter | Belgian Spring Wit | ??? Beer aroma sprayed over water. |
| Great South Bay Brewery | Massive IPA | okay. |
| Great South Bay Brewery | Marauder Bourbon Barrell-Aged Scotch Ale | Awesome! Nicely Balanced! |
| Greenport Harbor Brewing | Black Duck Porter | Roasted, not sweet. |
| Horseheads Brewing | Hot-Jala-Heim (2nd tasting) | Still Great! Hot stuff! |
| Keegan Ales | Mother's Milk, Bourbon Cask (2nd tasting) | Sublime again. |
| Kelso of Brooklyn | Bourbon Barrell-Aged Recessionator Doppelbock | Strong and Fantastic! A winner, worth coming back early for. |
| Rohrbach Brewing | Vanilla Porter | Excellent!!! |
| Rohrbach Brewing | Scotch Ale | Also nice. |
| Roosterfish Brewing | Roosterfish Belgian Tripel | Okay. A little too sweet. DNF. |
| Southampton Ales and Lagers | Double White Ale | Fruity and Crisp |
| Southampton Ales and Lagers | Saison Deluxe | Fruity, yeasty |
| Southampton Ales and Lagers | Doppelbock | Strong and crisp! |